Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Think. Again.

(20,794 posts)
6. I believe you might be wrongly hung up on the "middle class" thing.
Wed Jan 29, 2025, 09:09 PM
Yesterday

The financially-comfortable-but-not-excessively-rich status covers a huge portion of our population, including those that you point out in your post, -retired people (hippy or not) are mostly within the fiscal category of middle class, as are academics.

And AOC did not say "working class", which denotes a much smaller demographic which does exclude some of the groups you mention, but as you post says, she said "middle classv which is strictly a financial category.

As far as "brawler", I believe she just means someone who will fight hard and and long, and certainly not in the physical sense (because the Left doesn't do unnecessary violence).

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

It appears to me gab13by13 Yesterday #1
I totally disagree! tableturner Yesterday #2
A. I did not say I think Dems aren't doing enough. yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #13
you're right in a lot of what you say here. stopdiggin Yesterday #3
What "brawler" means in AOC's context.... tableturner Yesterday #7
I understand your point. yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #15
Did you see my correction on my OP? yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #27
and I agree with about 95% of what you had to say stopdiggin 22 hrs ago #34
The word choice is probably intended to evoke commitment. Frasier Balzov Yesterday #4
IMHO, you missed her point. Phoenix61 Yesterday #5
I agree...SCREW decorum! That's how the GOP kicks our asses! tableturner 23 hrs ago #10
I think the push back regarding the EO's in the past couple of days yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #16
I needed to make a correction in my OP. yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #18
I believe you might be wrongly hung up on the "middle class" thing. Think. Again. Yesterday #6
"Ocasio-Cortez said, we need to be a party of brawlers for the working class." yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #8
Cut and pasted from your OP above... Think. Again. 23 hrs ago #11
Your OP states it differently. Sailingfish 23 hrs ago #14
I have since realized that it wa indeed the phrase - "working class". yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #20
Thanks. No apologies needed at all. Sailingfish 23 hrs ago #25
Thank you for your gracious reply. yellow dahlia 22 hrs ago #31
Cheers Sailingfish 20 hrs ago #38
Thanks for clearing that up! Sorry about the confusion. Think. Again. 22 hrs ago #35
My apologies. There was a typo in my OP. yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #19
My take SilasSouleII 23 hrs ago #9
I'll agree. The word "brawlers" means a lot of things n I'm not getting hung up on a word. Her intent is more important Deuxcents 23 hrs ago #12
The phrase used by AOC was actually "working class. yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #23
the middle class made this country? try again. NoRethugFriends 21 hrs ago #37
The Revolutionary War ... Xoan 23 hrs ago #17
Freedom riders. CoopersDad 23 hrs ago #22
Here is a more full transcript of the exchange. Context matters. CoopersDad 23 hrs ago #21
She used that phrase in more than one interview. yellow dahlia 23 hrs ago #24
and that is actually WAY more disappointing stopdiggin 22 hrs ago #36
How I'm reading it Lulu KC 23 hrs ago #26
Thank you for your input and thoughts. yellow dahlia 22 hrs ago #29
The notion that Democrats need to be brawlers is spot on, gab13by13 22 hrs ago #28
I think the push back regarding the EO's in the past couple of days yellow dahlia 22 hrs ago #30
I like anyone that names themselves after a flower. Brogrizzly 22 hrs ago #32
Thank you. yellow dahlia 22 hrs ago #33
Working class for populists means rural white men in swing states who used to have good union manufacturing jobs betsuni 19 hrs ago #39
I don't know. Elessar Zappa 11 hrs ago #40
What if we are all of the above (or many of the above) - TBF 7 hrs ago #41
I think you may not understand the purpose of my post. yellow dahlia 3 hrs ago #42
Latest Discussions»The Way Forward»I realize I may get some ...»Reply #6