Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Lordquinton

(7,886 posts)
12. God describes something completely imaginary
Tue Sep 27, 2016, 04:24 PM
Sep 2016

and if you ask in the other room, the only true defining charistic is that he can't be defined.

A country is something very real.

Let's start on something a little smaller, like my office. There is a small cramped, stuffy room that is clearly defined by 4 walls and a door. It is known as my office (Or to other people, LQ's office), it's simply a common name we all use to differentiate it from other areas around.

The city is Concord, something that was agreed upon over time to describe everything in a certain area, it encompases many parks and houses, and buisness and offices that all have their own defined spaces and areas. It wasn't always called Concord, it was once called Todos Santos, and at one point was almost called Drunken Indian.

It is in Contra Costa County, which is a greater area that encompases many cities, that all have many buildings, houses, and offices all with their own name.

It's in California, which contains several counties, each with many cities, that all contain multitudes of houses, parks and offices, each with their own unique name and descriptor.

California is in the Country of the United States of America, which contains about 50 states, all with many counties, which all have many cities, that all have lots of buildings, hoses and offices.

the USA (for short) is on the continent of North America, which is what we designate for a defined landmass, that contains several countries, each with several states, that all have several counties, that all contain several cities, that all have a bunch of buildings, parks,. houses and offices.

The continent is on something we call a planet, which is a body of mass orbiting what we call a sun.

These are all real things that you can touch, see and visit (Well, maybe not visit the sun, but you can see it... just don't look at it) we give them all different names and divisions tso we can track them better and so there is less confusion. They are all clearly defined and all meet certain, if somewhat arbitrary, conditions.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

You're still on that? trotsky Sep 2016 #1
Visit Saudi Arabia and say Allah is bullshit and see how imaginary gods work for you. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #3
Yes, surprise surprise, words mean things to humans. trotsky Sep 2016 #5
Excellent questions. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #9
Well, an experiment you can try is to obtain a weapon, and charge at someone. trotsky Sep 2016 #10
I live in an area called "Montana." ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #13
You were looking for experimental data. trotsky Sep 2016 #25
I'm trying to get people to see the absurdity of the violence we support. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #28
When you use the word "imaginary" to describe countries or governments... trotsky Sep 2016 #31
Where do abstractions exist? ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #33
OK well you have fun then. n/t trotsky Sep 2016 #35
I have been. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #36
Ever notice a bunch of birds on an electric wire? Freelancer Sep 2016 #16
I gotta say tkmorris Sep 2016 #2
If we were Zen Buddhists I would take that as a compliment. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #4
I believe the concepts exist... uriel1972 Sep 2016 #6
People act as if God exists, ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #7
If you reduce god to a concept created by humans... uriel1972 Sep 2016 #8
I wonder how many who would be unhappy with the comparison for their own god(s) ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #14
God is arbitrary & imaginary, but at times useful -- like the yellow painted lines in a parking lot Freelancer Sep 2016 #18
Ha! ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #22
I never acquired a taste for religion...no one taught me anything about it.... Tikki Sep 2016 #11
God describes something completely imaginary Lordquinton Sep 2016 #12
Very good! ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #17
It has my name on the door Lordquinton Sep 2016 #19
I'm simply asking for evidence. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #21
It's assigned to me Lordquinton Sep 2016 #23
Do you think social contracts exist outside of the imagination? ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #27
Is god on a map? AlbertCat Sep 2016 #15
I'm trying, with my drunk brain, to make an argument ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #20
You seem to be making the observation that both national borders and god(s) are... NeoGreen Sep 2016 #24
We allow/support violence against those who cross imaginary lines without paperwork. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #29
Ahhh...sure..ok... NeoGreen Sep 2016 #32
I love D&D and I would definitely check out that church. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #34
Oh, that's easy. DetlefK Sep 2016 #26
Some countries have many languages, cultures, and values. ZombieHorde Sep 2016 #30
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»We abandon religious beli...»Reply #12