Religion

SarahD

(1,732 posts)

41. Attributed incorrectly.

Sun Feb 18, 2024, 03:19 PM

Feb 2024

Christian texts present these ideas as if Jesus thought of them for the first time, or at least independently. But these mostly humanist notions were around long before Jesus. That doesn't mean Jesus stole or plagiarized. He probably just preached generally recognized social values to his followers.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

67 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

There was no Jesus [View all] Celerity Feb 2024 OP

k&r nt flying rabbit Feb 2024 #1

At this point, does it matter? Ocelot II Feb 2024 #2

Everything matters - or ... dchill Feb 2024 #3

It only matters as an objective response to the Mike Johnsons of the world... Thunderbeast Feb 2024 #7

Bookmarking True Dough Feb 2024 #4

Good read. Fascinating analysis of the analysts. . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2024 #5

I think this is the earliest form of good marketing...nt mitch96 Feb 2024 #6

I think a lot of liberal Christians harumph Feb 2024 #8

I'll go with the Harry Potter analogy. Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #10

I take a more charitable view - but I'm not a literalist... harumph Feb 2024 #11

Using Flavius Josephus as a reference is a mistake Christians often make Doc Sportello Feb 2024 #34

And one of the references is now generally Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #63

Is that 'Christian', though? pandr32 Feb 2024 #55

Yeah but the vast majority of biblical historians, Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #9

Ok, did Siddhartha Gautama actually exist do you think? harumph Feb 2024 #12

I have no idea, and no. Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #15

The historical record is routinely altered. colorado_ufo Feb 2024 #14

The Roman Empire was generally tolerant Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #18

Interesting and informative. colorado_ufo Feb 2024 #28

But wasn't that how "Christianity" began.... Think. Again. Feb 2024 #52

Not sure about that. colorado_ufo Feb 2024 #59

To me, that seems to be the most logical conclusion... Think. Again. Feb 2024 #60

I think he is a composite character Mr.Bill Feb 2024 #13

And here's a composite drawing to go with that composite character: True Dough Feb 2024 #30

And another image based on forensic science True Dough Feb 2024 #32

Orange Jesus is real. twodogsbarking Feb 2024 #16

And yet, ideas attributed to him survived 2,000 years. surfered Feb 2024 #17

As a seeker, these are not unique to this religion I've found. slightlv Feb 2024 #22

These aren't necessarily him either angrychair Feb 2024 #26

The "Golden Rule" exists in all the major religious and spiritual traditions, Ocelot II Feb 2024 #29

You sure those weren't stolen True Dough Feb 2024 #35

About the beatitudes Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #36

Attributed incorrectly. SarahD Feb 2024 #41

But those are basic 'good' human traits that go all the way back, way before the Jesus thing, aren't they? Think. Again. Feb 2024 #53

👇👇👇👁️👁️ Goonch Feb 2024 #19

Kicking. MontanaMama Feb 2024 #20

"The Christian theory is little else than anciano Feb 2024 #21

I said something similar above, slightlv Feb 2024 #24

Imo, a person that came to be called Yeshua lonely bird Feb 2024 #23

I even asked my sister slightlv Feb 2024 #25

The repetition of ancient themes in christian myth orthoclad Feb 2024 #27

Jesus died again yesterday in Navalny's death Ponietz Feb 2024 #31

Thank you! pazzyanne Feb 2024 #38

The greatest lesson of the Bible - don't fuck with the men who has the money and the power Probatim Feb 2024 #56

Our calendar is all wrong then? pwb Feb 2024 #33

Just for the record, pazzyanne Feb 2024 #37

Just for the record, this forum is open Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #64

Just for the record - pazzyanne Feb 2024 #65

Your opinion is welcome. Voltaire2 Feb 2024 #66

Thank you, Voltaire2. pazzyanne Feb 2024 #67

Well twodogsbarking Feb 2024 #39

I cite, for example..... Shoonra Feb 2024 #40

No shooting an apple? No killing Gessler? SarahD Feb 2024 #43

A lot of earlier religions preached the same story. Emile Feb 2024 #42

Thought this theory was interesting & logical: Roman Emperors Invented Christianity Attilatheblond Feb 2024 #44

One bit of evidence that Jesus did exist thucythucy Feb 2024 #45

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Qutzupalotl Feb 2024 #46

It actually is evidence edhopper Feb 2024 #48

There was a revolution some years after his death Warpy Feb 2024 #47

I had heard that Christianity edhopper Feb 2024 #49

Washn't he dead by this time? Warpy Feb 2024 #57

Not Mark the Apostle edhopper Feb 2024 #58

An interesting observation edhopper Feb 2024 #50

Look up Jim Palmer AwakeAtLast Feb 2024 #51

I'm just getting started studying what I agree is the evolution of religion. I watched a lot of Bart Ehrman on his brewens Feb 2024 #54

Very peculiar presentation of this statistic: Qutzupalotl Feb 2024 #61

I like omnipotent beings that get it right the first time. czarjak Feb 2024 #62