Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

onenote

(45,328 posts)
27. The courts disagree
Tue May 13, 2025, 11:28 AM
May 13

See post #24.

The Congressional Budget Office and the GAO both are legislative branch agencies. The Library of Congress has been held to be an executive branch agency. Neither the CBO nor GAO are subject to the Administrative Procedure Act, the Library is. In the case of the CBO, the director is appointed by the Speaker of the House and the Senate's President Pro Tem. While GAO is headed by the Comptroller General, who is a presidential appointee, how the CG is appointed is the subject of a rather convoluted statutorily mandated procedure unlike anything applicable to the Librarian of Congress.

How the Comptroller General is Selected

The Congress established the current procedure for nominating a Comptroller General when it passed the GAO Act of 1980. Under the act, the Comptroller General is appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate. When a vacancy occurs in the office of the Comptroller General, the Congress establishes a commission to recommend individuals to the President. The commission consists of the following:

The Speaker of the House of Representatives
The President Pro Tempore of the Senate
The majority and minority leaders of the House of Representatives and the Senate
The Chairman and Ranking Member of the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
The Chairman and Ranking Member of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform
The commission must recommend at least three individuals to the President, and the President may request that the commission recommend additional individuals. The President then selects an individual from those recommended to nominate as the new Comptroller General. The President's nomination must be confirmed by the Senate. Comptrollers general are appointed for one nonrenewable 15-year term.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

How better to burn the books? And the Declaration of Independence, The Constitution, ... erronis May 12 #1
The theft of priceless American artifacts. Irish_Dem May 12 #2
The theft in many formats... slightlv May 12 #15
The scope and depth of the crimes is mind boggling. Irish_Dem May 13 #19
The crime spree keeps finding levels I couldn't have fathomed, yellow dahlia May 13 #30
I kept warning that Trump was a vicious, ruthless psychopath. Irish_Dem May 13 #34
Writers are going to have to up their writing game on crime novels slightlv May 13 #37
Except no one would believe a crime novel along the lines of the Trump Crime Family. Irish_Dem May 13 #38
Media critical of Trump and republicans will be off the shelves. And supportive DEI material. Norrrm May 12 #3
This is to let Elon steal copyrighted materials for his AI firm. SunSeeker May 12 #4
Not just Elon. All the AI bros. highplainsdem May 12 #6
it's all a joke Karch May 12 #5
Nothing is sacred, anymore. littlemissmartypants May 12 #7
Nothing is sacred - exactly. yellow dahlia May 13 #29
Can't wait to see who the next Poet Laureate is BaronChocula May 12 #8
OOOOH! Pick Kid Rock!! Pick Kid Rock!!! BurnDoubt May 12 #11
Oh my BaronChocula May 12 #16
The grift continues - he gets a justice department salary as well as the library of congress salary. And the MAGAts iluvtennis May 12 #9
It's like they meet every night just to decide bluestarone May 12 #10
I just read a post indicating this is a Legislative Branch Appointment... BurnDoubt May 12 #12
I saw the same thing about 30 minutes ago BumRushDaShow May 12 #13
this is what is being reported by Rachel NJCher May 12 #14
By statute the Librarian of Congress is appointed by the President with the advice and consent of Congress onenote May 12 #17
45 doesn't care, nor do the DOGE people, as none have a clue about the web of laws that created these agencies/Boards BumRushDaShow May 13 #22
No doubt, But my post wasn't directed at Trump or Doge onenote May 13 #24
"the president can't name the register of copyrights -- by law, that authority is vested in the Librarian of Congress." BumRushDaShow May 13 #31
We know Trump ignores the law. But that doesn't mean it isn't important to point out what the law actually is onenote May 13 #35
And his intransigence was my point BumRushDaShow May 13 #36
The congress doesn't care. choie May 13 #32
Yup BumRushDaShow May 13 #33
With respect to the Librarian, the post you saw is inaccurate. See post #24 onenote May 13 #25
It's like they're using AI to figure out how to break things fast. mahina May 13 #28
Congress is not executive branch department. Guess who's Library? (other than ultimately US citizen's in trust). . . nt Bernardo de La Paz May 13 #18
The Librarian is a Presidentially appointed 10-year termed person though BumRushDaShow May 13 #23
The courts disagree onenote May 13 #27
Thanks. Iinterested to see who the Senate confirms -- Blanche or Newlen. ancianita May 13 #20
Have they hired someone to dust the librarian's chair? JustABozoOnThisBus May 13 #21
I actually gave a lecture and served on a panel lapfog_1 May 13 #26
No more Dewey Decimal System kskiska May 13 #39
The Library of Congress has its own classification system onenote May 13 #40
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Justice Department's Todd...»Reply #27