Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

thesquanderer

(12,598 posts)
25. They didn't lie. They danced around the question with non-answers.
Fri Jan 17, 2025, 05:27 PM
Jan 2025

It's as if I were to ask you, "Hey B, would you consider murdering someone?" And you answer "I believe murder is illegal." Your answer would be true, and would imply that you wouldn't do it, but it doesn't actually answer the question. Similarly, these people were asked things like whether they agreed with how Roe vs Wade was decided, and they would answer talking about its status as settled law, established precedent, etc. but never actually saying that they agreed with the decision, and never saying that they would refuse to consider a challenge to it. They were focussed not on answering the question, but on how to avoid answering it.

Here's a good article on it. No direct lies, just a lot of weasel words and misdirection.

https://www.factcheck.org/2022/05/what-gorsuch-kavanaugh-and-barrett-said-about-roe-at-confirmation-hearings/

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Will ERA protect the rights of Trans? no_hypocrisy Jan 2025 #1
I doubt it DeepWinter Jan 2025 #21
The SCROTUS will nullify this in about 3 days. nt. Voltaire2 Jan 2025 #2
Nothing to nullify at this point FBaggins Jan 2025 #4
And 9-0 at that Polybius Jan 2025 #17
Here is the STATEMENT BumRushDaShow Jan 2025 #3
Statement of President Joe Biden on the Equal Rights Amendment LetMyPeopleVote Jan 2025 #5
Well Done Joe!!! MayReasonRule Jan 2025 #6
Sadly, SCantiGOP Jan 2025 #7
Yes. DavidDvorkin Jan 2025 #8
On what basis? There's no time limit in the Constitution. pnwmom Jan 2025 #9
Don't Think That's Been Litigated. GB_RN Jan 2025 #11
Every amendment passed since prohibition had a deadline MichMan Jan 2025 #12
The time limit itself was unconstitutional, then the whole Amendment might be Polybius Jan 2025 #15
Where in the Constitution does it say a state's approval can be rescinded? nt pnwmom Jan 2025 #26
Where does it say it can't? madville Jan 2025 #29
The same page that it says that they can't n/t Polybius Jan 2025 #33
It doesn't prohibit one either MichMan Jan 2025 #28
Congress can make its own rules for its own conduct. Igel Jan 2025 #31
I wouldn't say sadly, because it might be 9-0 Polybius Jan 2025 #24
If it has been the 'Law of the Land' for almost five years now, why hasn't anyone filed a lawsuit citing it? Jose Garcia Jan 2025 #10
Do it, Joe! One last home run! calimary Jan 2025 #13
I think Biden is taunting Trump who will bear the fault if he wipes it out. CTyankee Jan 2025 #19
Cite Article IV of the Consitution. Igel Jan 2025 #32
Huh, I also though Roe vs Wade was also 'Law of the Land'. republianmushroom Jan 2025 #14
It was "settled law," until it wasn't. (n/t) thesquanderer Jan 2025 #18
That's what the lying supreme court justices, appointed by the most notorious liar in history, said UNDER OATH. BComplex Jan 2025 #23
They didn't lie. They danced around the question with non-answers. thesquanderer Jan 2025 #25
I understand that. But they knew what they were being asked. Playing verbal gymnastics, under oath, BComplex Jan 2025 #34
I agree. But they were smart enough with their answers to avoid perjury. thesquanderer Jan 2025 #35
So how come it's not on Wiki yet? Polybius Jan 2025 #16
Not enough fanfare intrepidity Jan 2025 #20
That's what they said about Roe... sakabatou Jan 2025 #22
Post removed Post removed Jan 2025 #27
It's a nice gesture madville Jan 2025 #30
I heard this wouldn't be finalized because the archivist wouldn't accept it LymphocyteLover Jan 2025 #36
the fate of the amendment seems very much up in the air LymphocyteLover Jan 2025 #37
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Biden Says Equal Rights A...»Reply #25