Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

suegeo

(2,809 posts)
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 04:23 PM Jul 2024

The narrative is made by erasure and exclusion. Erasure

Last edited Fri Jul 26, 2024, 07:18 PM - Edit history (2)

Men Explain Things to Me
By Rebecca Solnit

I am re-reading this excellent book.

The author writes

I think a lot about …obliteration. …
I have a friend whose family tree has been traced back a thousand years, but no women existed on it.
She just discovered that she herself did not exist, but her brothers did. Her mother did not exist, and nor did her father’s mother. …There were no grandmothers.
…missing sisters, aunts mothers, grand mothers, great-great grand mothers, a vast population made to disappear on paper and in history.
Thus coherence—of patriarchy, or ancestry, of narrative—is made by erasure and exclusion.

The narrative is made by erasure and exclusion.

What an excellent book, for this and other reasons.

11 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

Skittles

(158,413 posts)
1. what kind of "family tree" doesn't include women?
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 04:33 PM
Jul 2024

wouldn't women be more definitive? I bet you cannot go back many generations where the "father" listed is NOT the father

 

Traurigkeit

(1,290 posts)
3. That why men have wanted women to disappear. Men know they are not the base or limbs of theFamily Tree
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 04:56 PM
Jul 2024

CrispyQ

(38,121 posts)
2. That must be one odd looking family tree.
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 04:39 PM
Jul 2024

I'm not sure I even get it. What if a family has only daughters & they only have daughters? Are they just deleted from the family tree? What happens when one of them finally has boy. Does a new branch magically appear? ???

suegeo

(2,809 posts)
4. Before the patriarchy, property moved through the female line.
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 06:49 PM
Jul 2024

The property flowed through women for thousands of years. Because women were certain the children they birthed, out of their own body were their children. Women could not be certain which male she might sleep with was the father. Was is Ian or was it Jacob or one of a hundred of men that woman was "with"

When the woman died, the property, the jewelry, the money of hers went to her daughters. Who she was sure were her own.

Then came the establishment of the patriarchy, where property and money flowed from the male to other males.
The bible (I'm no expert on that book) I believe is full of Boaz begat Obed of Ruth, and Salmon begat Boaz of Rachab.
The whole of Ruth reminds of Offred in the Handmaid's tale.

Women were to remain virgins until marriage. If they got impregnated, the man could be sure the male child was his. The property could move through the male lineage. If a women committed adultery, she could be stoned to death. The husband could not assume any child out of her body was his. I believe women who were raped met a similar fate.

The patriarchy made sure the money, the property, the everything, was made through the male lineage. Brutality ensured it.

English law 1765:

By marriage, the husband and wife are one person in law: that is, the very being or legal existence of the woman is suspended during the marriage.


She (the wife) doesn't exist anymore.

Her marriage is called her coverture. For this reason, a man cannot grant anything to his wife, or enter into covenant with her: for the grant would be to suppose her separate existence.

page 67 of "Men explain things to me" by Rebecca Solnit.

The woman does not exist anymore.

Today, my last name is my father's last name. My mother's maiden name got wiped out.

I have a cookbook of recipes submitted by women back 40-50 years ago. When the book was published all the female names were, for example, "Mrs. Arthur Nicholls" and "Mrs. Kevin Irwin".

Salute to Las Madres de la Plaza de Mayo which Solnit describes in her book. Disappear. Erased.

Kudos to Hannah Arendt for not using her husband's last name. Was Arendt her mother's maiden name. Wow that would be sweet if true.

To get it, to better understand the world from a female's perspective, I recommend this book, "Men explain things to me" by Rebecca Solnit. Go purchase the book, and toss some money at a female.

Please note to the men here: I am not trying to be insensitive or bigoted towards men. As writer Mel (Melanie) Hamlett points out, women are groomed from birth to be super sensitive toward the feelings of men. We have to be. We have to tip-toe around men's feelings, lest the men get angry and dole out corporal punishment to women. Or worse.
The stress this causes women can take years off our lives.

Also Haidmaids tale:
Men are afraid women are going to laugh at them
Women are afraid men are going to kill them.


BlueSky3

(697 posts)
7. When I got married many years ago,
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 07:28 PM
Jul 2024

I decided to take my husband’s last name. One of my friends criticized me for this and I told her, “What’s the difference whether I take one man’s name or another’s? At least I’ve chosen this one.”

I recently read that the whole system of male domination has existed for less than 10,000 years. Matriarchal and egalitarian societies still exist in the world today. But not here.

suegeo

(2,809 posts)
6. Beyonce Gives Kamala Harris Her Blessing to Use "Freedom" For Campaign
Fri Jul 26, 2024, 07:15 PM
Jul 2024
https://www.teenvogue.com/story/beyonce-kamala-harris-blessing-freedom-campaign

The music video of this song echoes the sentiment I'm feeling now.

Black women staring at each other through history. All the women who got erased.

Maybe I am misinterpreting Beyonce's art.
Mansplain it to me.

suegeo

(2,809 posts)
10. Is it just me, or is the Harris campaign trending Woolfian?
Sun Jul 28, 2024, 06:26 PM
Jul 2024

Beyoncé Gives Kamala Harris Her Blessing to Use “Freedom” For Campaign.
https://www.teenvogue.com/story/beyonce-kamala-harris-blessing-freedom-campaign

Some lyrics I find interesting:


I'ma wade, I'ma wave through the waters
Tell the tide, "Don't move"

I'ma wade, I'ma wave through your shallow love
Tell the deep I'm new

But mama don't cry for me, ride for me
Try for me, live for me
Breathe for me, sing for me
Honestly guidin' me
I could be more than I gotta be
Stole from me, lied to me, nation hypocrisy


I missed the American Ballet Theatre performance of Woolf-Works
Lucky for me, there are youtube videos of some of the performances.

https://www.metopera.org/season/2024-abt/woolf-works/

TRIGGER WARNING, Talks of suicide
Tuesday
Grand and elegiac, The Waves (1931) is Woolf’s most experimental novel, conceived in response to her own childlessness and the contrasting fierce maternity of her sister Vanessa. In the novel, the voices of six people growing from childhood to old age are punctuated by symbols of natural decay and renewal, the most important of which is the ever-returning sea. Responding to Woolf’s unique fascination with underwater imagery in all her writing, “Tuesday” merges themes of The Waves with a portrayal of the writer’s suicide by drowning. As Woolf counts her steps towards the river Ouse and her final journey, so too the world of her novel moves towards abstraction and silence.


Tell the deep I'm new, painting things blue.
To me, Beyoncé is fighting on. The blue is external**. It is nothing similar to the trigger warning above.

I am not a scholar. I am just trying to keep up with history as it unfolds in front of me.

All the talk of the blue wave, Beyoncé painting white walls blue, brings up a memory I have about seeing Renoir's Two Sisters (On the Terrace) in Chicago.
https://www.artic.edu/iiif/2/3a608f55-d76e-fa96-d0b1-0789fbc48f1e/full/1686,/0/default.jpg

The colors have to be seen in person. The painting stuck with me, so I did some research, for a few hours.
Red is the color of here and now.
Blue is the color of the eternal**. The woman is wearing a blue dress, a woman's body is external because it brings forth life.
The white, I am not sure. It might be about what color it might be painted in the future?

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Women's Rights & Issues»The narrative is made by ...