"Israel needs a political offensive to accompany its military offensive"

[LymphocyteLover]

Good piece from Max Boot-- whole thing is worth a read

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/10/24/israel-gaza-peace-strategy-political-offensive/

If Israel were to rely on special operations raids and airstrikes, it would be reverting to the “mowing the lawn” strategy it followed for years of trying to degrade and deter, but not defeat, Hamas. The 10/7 attack revealed that policy’s failure by showing that Hamas actually grew stronger and bolder after previous Israeli assaults. Israel’s goal now, understandably enough, is for Hamas to be “crushed and eliminated.” There is simply no way to achieve that objective without a major ground offensive.

Of course, there is no guarantee that Israel’s ground attack will be successful. Urban warfare is extremely difficult under the best of circumstances. Hamas has had years to build formidable defenses, including hundreds of miles of tunnels. Israel runs the risk of being trapped in costly guerrilla warfare without end while an international backlash builds against the loss of civilian life. Iran and Hezbollah could use the opportunity to open a new front against Israel in the north. Those dangers are very real. Even so, one should assume that Israel has well-developed plans for a military offensive.

Yet Israeli leaders also desperately need to come up with better plans for a political offensive to limit the fallout from its military operations and create the potential for a more lasting peace to emerge from the current bloodletting. So far, though, there is little indication that Israeli planners are thinking in those terms. If the Israeli military goes charging into the Gaza Strip without any idea of what the political end state will look like, it will be repeating the same error that the George W. Bush administration made in Iraq and Afghanistan — and likely consigning Israeli troops to years of costly, onerous and morale-sapping occupation duties.

It is, admittedly, very difficult to imagine how Israel could stabilize Gaza post-Hamas without taking charge once again. The Washington Institute for Near East Policy has come out with the best blueprint I’ve seen so far. Its experts — Robert Satloff, Dennis Ross and David Makovsky — suggest that Israel could establish an interim Palestinian administration to run the Gaza Strip until the Palestinian Authority could take over. Five Arab states that have peace agreements with Israel — Egypt, Jordan, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Morocco — could send security forces to help keep order. International organizations could rush in aid, and Israel could promise to lift the blockade that has immiserated Gaza ever since the Hamas takeover in 2007.

[BootinUp]

1. K&R