Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Deminpenn

(16,267 posts)
Wed Feb 23, 2022, 12:31 PM Feb 2022

PA Supreme Court approves new congressional district map

This was just on the local noon news here.

The map looks good, compact district with few municipalities divided although the City of Pittsburgh is divided about in half. The northern and western part of Allegheney county that were in the old PA-17 being expanded in the new PA-17. This is still probably a swingish district as the northern part of Allegheney county is more conservative.

The new map throws to two R incumbents into the same district that is essentially the Allegheney National Forest and state game lands counties above I-80 and east of Erie.

https://www.post-gazette.com/news/politics-state/2022/02/23/pennsylvania-new-congressional-map-state-supreme-court-vote-democratic-republican-districts/stories/202202230100

8 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
PA Supreme Court approves new congressional district map (Original Post) Deminpenn Feb 2022 OP
New map Deminpenn Feb 2022 #1
Huge cilla4progress Feb 2022 #2
Yes, although because of the Court's ruling in 2018, Deminpenn Feb 2022 #3
This is awesome, and it's great for PA Dems FakeNoose Feb 2022 #4
Another view of the map BumRushDaShow Feb 2022 #5
The state legislative districts were a lot more fairly drawn by the Deminpenn Feb 2022 #6
You can enter your address on this site to see your old and new political districts: Dark n Stormy Knight Feb 2022 #7
The new CD map was drawn using "least change" criteria Deminpenn Feb 2022 #8

Deminpenn

(16,267 posts)
3. Yes, although because of the Court's ruling in 2018,
Wed Feb 23, 2022, 12:51 PM
Feb 2022

all of the maps pretty much reflected the state's partisan registration split. This map was submitted by the same group of Dem voters who sued to have the 2018 map declared unconstitutional.

As for the new CDs, PA 17 lost its portion of Butler county and gained part of Allegheny county. PA 1, I believe, picked up a sliver of Montgomery county which might be enough to tip the balance to D if this is true.

Centre county is now part of PA 15. I don't think it's enough to make this district competitive, but that county is the largest population area and likely the only one that's growing.

CD 10 might be more swingy, not good for incumbent insurrectionist Scott Perry.

I'll be intersted to see what happens in PA-11 which is almost entirely Lancaster county. For years now, sprawl has been creeping into Lancaster. It could be on the same path as Chester county.

According to 538, the map produces 8R, 6D, 3 swing.

FakeNoose

(35,554 posts)
4. This is awesome, and it's great for PA Dems
Wed Feb 23, 2022, 01:25 PM
Feb 2022

Now we don't have to waste another 8 years fighting the Repukes like we did after the 2010 census.

Your comment is interesting about Lancaster County. I have a dear old friend in Lancaster for many years. Even though he's a progressive Dem, he's surrounded by "red" everywhere in Lancaster. It's not just that they're conservative Republicans, but they're rabid Trumpers everywhere, even the Amish. Or maybe I should say, especially the Amish. Same friend knows many people in Chester County because he used to work there. Seems Chester is going the other way, becoming more urbanized and "bluer" every year.



BumRushDaShow

(141,653 posts)
5. Another view of the map
Wed Feb 23, 2022, 03:33 PM
Feb 2022


Pa. Supreme Court court picks national Dems’ map as new congressional plan

By: Stephen Caruso - February 23, 2022 11:41 am


Pennsylvania’s highest court has picked a map submitted by voters backed by a national group aligned with Democrats to be the commonwealth’s next congressional map.

In a 5-page order, the state Supreme Court ordered 4-3 that the map, known as the Carter plan, be adopted as soon as possible. An opinion was not immediately available. Four of the courts five liberal justices signed onto the order, while the other, Justice Debra Todd, joined two justices elected as Republicans in dissent.

The map was filed with the court by plaintiffs linked to the National Redistricting Action Fund, a dark money affiliate of National Democratic Redistricting Committee, while the case was argued by Democratic attorney Marc Elias.

https://www.penncapital-star.com/government-politics/pennsylvania-court-picks-national-dems-map-as-new-congressional-plan/





Marc E. Elias
@marceelias
🚨BREAKING: Pennsylvania Supreme Court ADOPTS new congressional map. Court selects maps put forward by our clients (Carter) as new statewide map!

Proud of the work @EliasLawGroup and @RedistrictFdn did to ensure fair maps in Pennsylvania.
democracydocket.com
🚨 Voting Rights Victory in Pennsylvania
Read about the latest voting rights victory in Carter v. Chapman.
11:29 AM · Feb 23, 2022


If Marc Elias is good with it so am I (and his group was the legal team behind the map that was chosen)!

And as a note to the slur that the Penn Capitol-Star did - the NDRC is Eric Holder's organization that has been dedicated to getting fair districts and not the RW loon gerrymandered crap. We have suffered here in PA for the past 10 years due to their last nonsense. I am hoping that when it comes to the state legislative districts, we can get those fixed too.

This was a bit tricky because PA lost a seat so a decision had to be made as to where. The population loss happened on the western side of the state and a gain in the east. And thankfully, the current map that the state Supreme Court implemented in 2018 already had a good base to start from and really, only needed some tweaking.

The initial analysis basically indicates that with this new map, you have 8 (D) seats + 8 (R) seats + 1 seat that is a mix that would be up for grabs. We are currently 9 (D) - 9 (R) after the 2018 map implementation that finally got rid of the gerrymandered atrocity that had been enacted by the loons after the last census in 2011, and that had 13 (R) - 5 (D) seats.

Deminpenn

(16,267 posts)
6. The state legislative districts were a lot more fairly drawn by the
Wed Feb 23, 2022, 04:45 PM
Feb 2022

Legislative Redistricting Committee. The LRC undid a good bit of the extreme gerrymandering the Rs did in 2010 and prior. For example, my HD went from meadering around the Dem areas to now being concentrated in the NE portion of Beaver County. It's still an R district, but not as much as before. Whoever represents it will now have to consider the needs of a much more demographically and economically diverse community all with different and sometimes conflicting needs. The analyses I read concluded Dems might pick up 10 seats or so and perhaps even re-take the state House. If that happened, the House would be almost 50-50 either way.

The new maps passed 4-1 with both Ds, Nordenberg and Senate Majority Leader Ward voting to approve. Ward liked the Senate map and said her duty was to that body. Benninghoff is mad about the House despite it still favoring Rs. I'm sure will object, or has already, but not sure anything will come of it.

Dark n Stormy Knight

(10,018 posts)
7. You can enter your address on this site to see your old and new political districts:
Wed Feb 23, 2022, 11:36 PM
Feb 2022
https://www.spotlightpa.org/news/2021/12/pennsylvania-redistricting-house-senate-districts-lookup-tool/

In two out of three of my districts, US House, PA Senate, PA House, the percentage of Democrats decreased. Not by much, but every little bit helps, or hurts.

US CONGRESS: Current Rep is a Democrat

Old Map
Democrats: 43.83%
Republicans: 38.58%
Others: 17.58%

New Map
Democrats: 43.78%
Republicans: 38.68%
Others: 17.54%


PA HOUSE: PA State Rep is currently a Republican

Old Map:
Democrats: 36.04%
Republicans: 46.52%
Others: 17.44%

New Map
Democrats: 36.78%
Republicans: 45.45%
Others: 17.77%


PA SENATE: PA State Senator is currently a Democrat

Old Map
Democrats: 44.37%
Republicans: 37.52%
Others: 18.11%

New Map
Democrats: 43.34%
Republicans: 39.11%
Others: 17.54%


Deminpenn

(16,267 posts)
8. The new CD map was drawn using "least change" criteria
Wed Feb 23, 2022, 11:41 PM
Feb 2022

The CD partisan split shouldn't change that much.

On the state House side, my HD became about 6 pts more Dem although still an R majority.

Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Pennsylvania»PA Supreme Court approves...