General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums2024: 69% of White men, no degree, voted Krasnov.
White women, no degree, were not much better, Krasnov 63-35
https://www.cnn.com/election/2024/exit-polls/national-results/general/president/
The White working class are not our base, and won't be coming back in numbers for one outstanding reason -
We should advocate raising the minimum wage, strengthening Unions and defending Medicaid because it is the right thing to do, not because it will win those voters back;
Far more encouraging the is the movement of White college educated voters towards the Democratic Party.
White women, college degree, Harris 58-42
White men, college degree, Krasnov 50-48.
March 2025 - Senator Sanders said the working class are the future of the Democratic Party
https://tinyurl.com/2vczaj7r
He is wrong. No there is no class divide amongst Voters of Color
Voters of Color, no degree, Harris 64-34
Voters of Color, college degree, Harris 65-32
The exodus of the white working class from the Democratic Party got underway with the Reagan Democrats, and has continued ever since. Bernie is pining for the good old days, but they are not coming back. "Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you." We can't out compete the Republicans on hate.
hlthe2b
(112,937 posts)Try as he might to help them, he knew the score.
Blue Owl
(58,235 posts)speak easy
(12,595 posts)MAGA votes for him to hurt people.;
littlemissmartypants
(31,773 posts)Ping Tung
(4,151 posts)mahatmakanejeeves
(68,394 posts)speak easy
(12,595 posts)Keepthesoulalive
(2,134 posts)When they dont extend it to others. Please stop believing anything you say or dont say will change their minds. The hate is baked in. Oh yeah the president they voted for is a pedo and a pedo enabler.
JustAnotherGen
(37,628 posts)It's a choice they've made to be that way.
no_hypocrisy
(54,377 posts)an authoritarian father figure.
kimbutgar
(26,898 posts)Blacks for the orange pedo felon. The owner was a white woman and in her basement was a poster of all the presidents with JFK being in the center.
But the brochure was hilarious and talked about how the OPP supported black people and was a defender of civil rights. I laughed so loud my co worker was startled. I brought it home and will post some of it. But hes been known as a racist like forever!
Mysterian
(6,191 posts)Fox "News" and all the other vile propaganda sewers. Telling whites they are oppressed and blaming all the problems of the world on immigrants and minorities. Well, it worked. Propaganda works. And when the rule of law is re-established in this country, we better take action to ensure fairness and honesty in the media. No more outright lies and no more patterns of misleading viewers. Shut that shit down because pervasive propaganda is like cancer in our society.
littlemissmartypants
(31,773 posts)Misinformation and disinformation every chance I get. There is an important distinction between them and it's easy to remember.
Disinformation (think 'D') is the deliberate sharing of misinformation.
Propaganda depends on it.
❤️
GoodRaisin
(10,749 posts)Fox News is still pushing all the same wedge crap about men in women sports, woke ideology, sanctuary cities etc. Krasnov goes on Fox News and lies about grocery prices. Those viewers live in a different world, Fox world, where they dont talk about Krasnovs lies or his tarriff tax hike. If Democrats want to break Foxs hold on white non educated voters they have got to find a way to push back on all those lies. Effectively. MSNBC is not the answer. Fox has villified MSNBC so none of those white uneducated eyes are on it.
NoMoreRepugs
(11,819 posts)in todays ReichWing news bubble is IMO the principal reason we are where we are.
lostnfound
(17,420 posts)these exit polls are manipulated heavily. They are NOT raw data and they are NOT random. Look at the states in which polling was done:
Arizona
Florida
Georgia
Michigan
North Carolina
Ohio
Pennsylvania
Texas
Wisconsin
Thats it. They are presented as some conclusive national story, but theres no polling in California or New York? Look at the button on the top left, you can see the states:
https://www.cnn.com/election/2024/exit-polls/north-carolina/general/president/0
Even the numbers on that page that purport to represent that state are also manipulated, NOT raw data in this case, to match the reported outcome.
Why do they do polling Texas but not California or New York?
We dont have facts; we have more propaganda.
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)Things have flipped.
Yes we have to appeal to the working class.
speak easy
(12,595 posts)Yes, but chasing the white working class is a fools errand.
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)Trump won it 56-42 in 2024.
That's 12 years of bad politics to lose them.
Trump has painted the GOP as the Party of the working class... he's lying of course... but that's an argument we're losing.
speak easy
(12,595 posts)Double down on our base & GOTV - not chase working class white men. 69% Krasnov. That 69% deserve what coming to them.
Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you. That's the point.
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)And we're not going to win MI and PA and GA focusing on a base that is mostly urban, educated and higher income.
Biden, in 2020 promised to boost the base Social Security benefit. It never happened.
Trump's whole "forgotten voter" shtick is laughable... but it worked.
The face of the Party needs to be a moderate who is personally non-threatening to voters, even GOP voters.
But he should govern from the Left.
Kinda like both Clinton and Obama.
speak easy
(12,595 posts)"But he should govern from the Left."
Now that I totally agree with. What I am saying is do not to expect the white working class to running back because they are better off = they are prepared to be worse off if a party can give them people to hate. that was LBJ's point, and he was right.
69% Krasnov :shakes head:
Bettie
(19,324 posts)who spits out a few catch phrases, in a mild voice, while promising to keep the status quo?
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)Ya know... say the right things in election season to be non-threatening and then nominates Sotomayor or Kagan or creates the greatest Gov't program in decades.
Dan
(4,995 posts)But the reality was hidden and translated as the party of the white men.
Southern strategy made modern to appeal via the internet.
Can Democrats recover the white majority, sure there are ways.
1. Bring back segregation;
2. Eliminate DEI (which really impacts white females);
3. Guarantee that every white man has a job regardless of qualifications;
4. Stop immigration from those countries;
5. Allow housing discrimination and exclusion laws again;
6. Outlaw certain interracial relations (just the ones that impact white
Females, not white men);
Just a few little things and hell, to get damn near get 100% of those voters that were loss as a result of the Civil Rights Acts of the 1960s
. Just add lynching back to the national pastimes. With that youll even get the law enforcement votes (especially the sheriffs).
IMO.
Policies don't matter to these people - Culture does.
You've nailed their culture.
Bluestocking
(523 posts)So long as POC have equal rights as whites the white working class will not vote democratic.
betsuni
(28,768 posts)So many good books about how the Republican Party came to this point. '70s creation of right-wing think tanks, building a conservative direct mail audience not only politically but to sell stuff to them as they still do with their media empire bubble, courting evangelicals, eventually becoming a non-governing batty reality show you can't turn off.
Will be interesting to see how long the both sides blame Democrats for imaginary corruption remnants will still be at it with strongly worded speeches and vigorously wagging fingers, back to the future of the '60s.
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)And Trump winning them 56-42 in 2024.
I'll wait.
betsuni
(28,768 posts)In 2008 there were about the same number of white Democrats and Republicans. Now the Republican Party is overwhelmingly the white party. No policies help the working/middle classes, it's all identity and culture wars. Trump is right-wing hate radio brought to life. 1hat's what they love. Whites began leaving the Democratic Party in the '60s when economic inequality was at it's lowest, plenty of high wage union manufacturing jobs. Nothing to do with "economic anxiety."
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)Romney and McCain received almost the same number of votes.
Look at Obama.
He was a cautious politician, believed in the Jordan adage, "Republicans buy sneakers, too"
A human flamethrower may have worked for the GOP twice... but I think we need another Obama or Clinton to win again.
BumRushDaShow
(166,152 posts)This lily-white woman (whose ancestors traced back to Ireland) -

and her lily-white parents -

Remember this "imagery"? -

He even took a trip to Moneygall, Ireland where his mother's ancestors descended -

Now add an IRISH Vice President (who would give Obama "white street cred", with the "assumption" that he would really be the one "governing" ), and that was enough to take him over the top (even with the lesser turnout 2012 election).
This is why the racist dreck of the GOP kept trying to wrest their base's "vision" away from Obama's mother's family in order to point them to his father's Kenyan family, where they could go full blown racist CT using them. Not all bought it obviously.
Until we FUCKING DEAL WITH THE RACIAL OVERLAY that has been in this country since before its founding, we will continue to swing and miss.
As speak easy has so noted (and here is the source) -
Bill D. Moyers
WHAT A REAL PRESIDENT WAS LIKE
November 12, 1988
WHILE Lyndon Baines Johnson was a man of time and place, he felt the bitter paradox of both. I was a young man on his staff in 1960 when he gave me a vivid account of that southern schizophrenia he understood and feared. We were in Tennessee. During the motorcade, he spotted some ugly racial epithets scrawled on signs.
Late that night in the hotel, when the local dignitaries had finished the last bottles of bourbon and branch water and departed, he started talking about those signs. "I'll tell you what's at the bottom of it," he said. "If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you."
Some years later when Johnson was president, there was a press conference in the East Room. A reporter unexpectedly asked the president how he could explain his sudden passion for civil rights when he had never shown much enthusiasm for the cause. The question hung in the air. I could almost hear his silent cursing of a press secretary who had not anticipated this one.
But then he relaxed, and from an instinct no assistant could brief -- one seasoned in the double life from which he was delivered and hoped to deliver others -- he said in effect: Most of us don't have a second chance to correct the mistakes of our youth. I do and I am. That evening, sitting in the White House, discussing the question with friends and staff, he gestured broadly and said,
"Eisenhower used to tell me that this place was a prison. I never felt freer." For weeks in 1964, the president carried in his pocket the summary of a Census Bureau report showing that the lifetime earnings of an average black college graduate were lower than that of a white man with an eighth-grade education. And when The New York Times in November 1964 reported racial segregation to be increasing instead of disappearing, he took his felt-tip pen and scribbled across it "shame, shame, shame," and sent it to Everett Dirksen, the Republican leader in the Senate. I have a hard time explaining to our two sons and daughter -- now in their twenties -- that when they were little, America was still deeply segregated.
(snip)
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)BumRushDaShow
(166,152 posts)His campaign apparatus made that "a thing". BIG TIME. It was a central part of his campaign along with "We're not 'red states' and 'blue states'; we're all Americans" (alternately "we're the United States" ).
Remember the marketing and logo even mimicked Raygun's "Morning in America" (from the speech) -

Before Deval Patrick was elected Governor of Massachusetts in 2006 as the 2nd black governor of a state (after Doug Wilder), black candidates were lucky to get maybe 25% of the white vote. Axelrod was able to get the boost to somewhere around 30+% for Patrick in 2006 (where he broke a streak of (R) governors in MA), and was able to even eclipse that for Obama just 2 years later in 2008.
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)Agreed?
His 08 campaign should be aspirational for all in 28
BumRushDaShow
(166,152 posts)something that too many on DU still don't "get".
In the case of Harris - another biracial candidate who ran for President - her mother wasn't "white" but was Asian, so that was "not enough" - even with Walz on the ticket.
electric_blue68
(26,054 posts)Obama was not the first time I voted for a Black candidate...
I do remember but not if this was pre-election - the thing Obama maitaining a certain demeanor; so he wouldn't appear "the angry Blackman" trope.
Part of that demeanor was honest, and real. It's possible he deliberately at times restricted his emotional range in public.
progree
(12,752 posts)and they don't care one whit whether he was partly Black or entirely Black.
At least in my necks (plural) of the woods, and I've lived all across the country, if you are part Black, unless you are a really pale version that can sometimes pass as white, the racists hate you as much as if you are 100% Black.
The harsh reality of the situation is that most traditional African Americans -- those with roots here in the U.S. going back more than 150 years -- are not 100% Black. And they don't get any kind of "break" from racist-inclined whites for not being totally Black.
I had a half white - half black girlfriend for years (her mother was 100% white, father was traditional African American), and she talked about being ostracized in some situations.
I must admit I missed the ads where he presented himself as only partly Black, but even back then, I didn't watch much TV. If they did see those ads, it was seen by many as the "Mongrelization Of The White Race" and "miscegenation", and "The Great Replacement"
littlemissmartypants
(31,773 posts)electric_blue68
(26,054 posts)Dawson Leery
(19,530 posts)Justice Brandeis
(405 posts)And that is do-able.
littlemissmartypants
(31,773 posts)Where the are and work from there?
Be a uniter and not a divider?
I love statistics more than most probably. Because I made them a part of how I made a living, but statistics can lie. The analysis is only as good as the individual establishing the design.
I prefer a more personalized, humanistic approach.
WarGamer
(18,257 posts)It's called the "LibsofTikTok Effect"
The right has painted an extreme caricature of Democrats and instead of Democrats responding by saying "that's silly, get real"... they defend whatever is mocked in the video.
99% of the GOP believes the "kitty litter boxes in school classrooms for kids who identify as cats" hoax.
It was always a hoax.
But no one pushed back, only saying "Don't be a bigot" as if defending the fake premise of the hoax.
littlemissmartypants
(31,773 posts)The white man vs....?
And the educated vs....?
The gig worker vs. the stay at home mom?
The races pitted against one another for example.
The labels that divide us.
Not the pure nonsense rambling of the insane.
Keepthesoulalive
(2,134 posts)Billionaires make money from division. The populace must not buy into it. But they do with glee. Because of greed and proud ignorance we all suffer. So I am asking again, how do you get through to people who wallow in the right wing sewer.
littlemissmartypants
(31,773 posts)There are three distinct and documented types of motivation.
1. Internal: the individual needs to desire change.
2. External: the individual needs a reward or payment as in something they perceive has value in exchange for their transformation.
And ...
3. Punishment.
That's it. So, it has to be one or all of them.
Keepthesoulalive
(2,134 posts)I thought recession but he is so insane it is likely to be a depression unless republicans grow spines.
AverageOldGuy
(3,390 posts)is the destruction of the middle class due to job loss (72% of which is to robots), increased taxes, increased cost of medical care, etc. all of which was blamed on Democrats by Rush Limbaugh and his minions.
CousinIT
(12,292 posts)ananda
(34,497 posts)If you code your language correctly, and create lies that
could seem true, then you can get the lower classes to vote
for you... even though you actually only represent rich,
corporate interests.
DemocratSinceBirth
(101,658 posts)questionseverything
(11,629 posts)But I think its more young black males than black women
markodochartaigh
(5,079 posts)It isn't a split between Democratic voters and Republican voters.
It is a split between Democratic voters, Republican voters, AND, those who don't vote. This is as true of the working class category as it is of all other categories.
I think that the only way to break through the propaganda bubble that has poisoned the working class for decades is a major trauma, like a deep recession. So the reich-wing propagandized working class are not going to swing suddenly to vote Democratic no matter what the Democratic party does.
BUT. The non-voters in the working class maybe reachable. And there are a lot of them, 20-25%. Enough to swing the working class demographic in most of the US.
Is it possible to deprogram White national evangelicals? Yes, but that is exactly what it is, deprogramming, a long and intensive process. Possible and worth it if the person is your friend or relative, but not really workable on a mass scale.
Education and motivation of the apathetic non-voters is much more practical.
BaronChocula
(4,063 posts)I don't think the Democratic Party advocates for raising wages, strengthening unions and protecting Medicaid to appeal to those in question. They (we) do it because it's a foundational part of the the Democratic philosophy.
What would be great to see is the Party do is apply some psyops. You can't get those people to love Dems, but you can drive a wedge between them and their beliefs by convincing them they've been listening to the wrong white people since they view everything threw a "cultural" lens rather than a policy lens. I think they can be convinced that dead Limbaugh who was wealthy bamboozled them into abandoning their interests in favor of tax breaks for the rich. They should be told that the white people with or without college degrees who are doing better all live happily in Blue States. It doesn't need to be a data-driven message (it doesn't have to be totally true). it should just be repeated repeated repeated.
In spite of where we are, I've been encouraged by seeing more liberal white rural social media personalities over the past couple of years. It pokes holes in the "coastal elite" myth. Libs are everywhere, perhaps outnumbered in some places, but still everywhere.
Karasu
(2,003 posts)speak easy
(12,595 posts)The 'Deplorables' are quite prepared to be worse off provided the people they hate are badly hurt by Kransov et. al. It's cruelty, not stupidity that got Krasnov over the line.
Karasu
(2,003 posts)It's the only possible explanation I can see for the last 10 years alone.
NoMoreRepugs
(11,819 posts)female or minority Democratic candidate IMO.
speak easy
(12,595 posts)doc03
(38,857 posts)oasis
(53,372 posts)mucholderthandirt
(1,760 posts)When we kept reaching across that aisle, we became just a weaker version of the Republicans. The lower the working class falls, the more they decide to just vote R and let them handle the people they hate.
I'm not sure there's enough college educated white people to keep Dems in office. There may be some chance if we can keep the non-white voters, and gain more, but it's not looking good at the moment. Oh, sure, people will eventually vote to get rid of the MAGA element, but as soon as things are better, they'll start being mad that the "colored" people are doing well, and there we go again.
I'm white, Southern, no college degree, but I believe in people being treated fairly, the same, with government help as needed, better schools, job safety, a good environment and all that. I'm basically a JFK liberal. Probably a bit more left than that, even. I am not, technically a Democrat, but they're the closest I can get to someone who can win. If only they didn't disappoint me so often.
OldBaldy1701E
(10,290 posts)Two things.
One, we don't know that. We might have more hidden rage than their racist, ignorant views give them.
Two, we don't have to 'out-rage' them. We just have to rage against them.
"Do not go quietly into that good night. Rage, rage against the dying of the light." - Dylan Thomas. This also means to rage against those who are causing that dying. We have to understand that it is the only thing that they will acknowledge.