Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 06:29 AM Tuesday

Experts, education, science have no value in America's new fascist regime.

In fascist regimes the educated are considered a serious threat to the regime,
the educated are painted as a societal evil and must be destroyed.

(In contrast, in a democracy, education is revered because a democracy cannot
exist without an educated populace. )

Truth, reality, right and wrong must be eradicated in a fascist regime.

Hitler killed the educated elite first thing when he invaded Poland.

Stalin in Russia did a great purge, including the intellectuals, killed or sent to camps.

China also did a great purge, calling it the cultural revolution.
The educated were killed or sent to concentration camps for the rest of their lives doing hard labor.

Two new neighbors where I live are an older Chinese couple, who fled China recently.

The husband is an educated, very smart journalist who wrote less than complementary
articles about the Chinese government. Basically they left China with the clothes on their
back, left all their valuables behind.

If he returns to China he will be arrested or worse.

His father was one of the university professors arrested during the great purge
and sent to labor camps for the rest of his life. I will spare you the grisly details.

48 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Experts, education, science have no value in America's new fascist regime. (Original Post) Irish_Dem Tuesday OP
Our Freedoms Are Reason Based. When Delusion Rules Our Freedoms Cease To Exist In Application MayReasonRule Tuesday #1
And perhaps, most egregiously, LOGIC/CRITICAL THINKING has no place in no_hypocrisy Tuesday #2
Yes also remember the "weapons of mass destruction" lies to promote the invasion of Iraq. Irish_Dem Tuesday #3
But, but yellow cake... rubbersole Tuesday #8
And funnel a huge amount of money to his company Halliburton. Irish_Dem Tuesday #22
There were reports that proved that no WMD. Blue Full Moon Tuesday #10
Yes this is why I put that in quotes. It was a total lie. Irish_Dem Tuesday #21
Americans can't help buy the lies ... Charging Triceratops Tuesday #27
The US media is the propaganda arm of the PutinGOP. Irish_Dem Tuesday #29
for me it was an interview with Karl Rove, barbtries Tuesday #11
That was a turning point. Thanks Evolve Dammit Tuesday #16
This is the Vietnam story as well. Simeon Salus Tuesday #4
Uneducated are easily controlled. Blue Full Moon Tuesday #5
Yes exactly. Irish_Dem Tuesday #6
Ohio has some insidious evangelicals Blue Full Moon Tuesday #13
Yes NASA has been working hard on stem and especially getting women into stem. Irish_Dem Tuesday #23
I drove across Ohio two years ago ... Charging Triceratops Tuesday #28
Yes the media takeover has been complete. Blue Full Moon Tuesday #33
Even decent, educated people can be naive. Many are reared to be trusting and to allegorical oracle Tuesday #7
Yes true. But education is the cornerstone of democracy. Irish_Dem Tuesday #9
Oh certainly. And perhaps that's a difference between MAGA followers and those allegorical oracle Tuesday #14
Good point. Irish_Dem Tuesday #24
One that the republicans have been eroding Blue Full Moon Tuesday #17
And to know how our system works .. LSparkle Tuesday #19
it's true. barbtries Tuesday #12
Nor empathy surfered Tuesday #15
Yes, empathy, kindness, respect, public service are now quaint old fashioned values. Irish_Dem Tuesday #25
The "Know Nothing" party in the 1800's lives on? Evolve Dammit Tuesday #18
Had a friend that was a professor that taught English as a Second Language. multigraincracker Tuesday #20
I agree. Irish_Dem Tuesday #32
Here is part of the issue as I see it. OldBaldy1701E Tuesday #26
Getting an education now is about making the billionaires richer. Irish_Dem Tuesday #30
Exactly! (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Tuesday #31
That's why the student loans Blue Full Moon Tuesday #35
I wonder who gets rich on student loans? Irish_Dem Tuesday #36
Koch's were the ones that fought Biden Blue Full Moon Tuesday #38
Americans are victims of ongoing scams designed to make the rich richer. Irish_Dem Tuesday #41
Very true. OldBaldy1701E Tuesday #42
"Outcome-Based Education" us an example of this. John1956PA Tuesday #39
Play dumb and get to work bucolic_frolic Tuesday #34
The billionaire scams and corruption of US politicians and judges will cause a collapse eventually? Irish_Dem Tuesday #37
Sure, they are going to arrest themselves. Blue Full Moon Tuesday #40
I agree, Americans seem to love being scammed, lied to and manipulated. Irish_Dem Tuesday #43
It's all a vulture signaling contest from here on out. Hugin Tuesday #44
exactly Blue_Tires 12 hrs ago #46
Brilliant metaphors. Irish_Dem 11 hrs ago #47
We're in a post-truth, post-fact society Blue_Tires 12 hrs ago #45
Yes truth, reality, facts are no longer in vogue. Irish_Dem 11 hrs ago #48

MayReasonRule

(1,963 posts)
1. Our Freedoms Are Reason Based. When Delusion Rules Our Freedoms Cease To Exist In Application
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 06:42 AM
Tuesday

Our country's long and sordid history of enshrining "closely held beliefs" a.k.a. delusion as the rule of law has brought us to today.

Reason gives birth to reason.
Delusion gives birth to delusion.

It is impossible to reason with those that reject reason itself.

May reason rule.

no_hypocrisy

(49,507 posts)
2. And perhaps, most egregiously, LOGIC/CRITICAL THINKING has no place in
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 06:45 AM
Tuesday

America's new fascist regime.

Lies are Truth. Lies are "Alternative Facts". Facts are Lies. Inconsistency is complex rationality.

And in court cases that go up to the USSC, precedence is discretionary.

I remember when I first started to notice this: George W. Bush and his AG, Alberto Gonzalez. As White House counsel, then as Bush's hand-picked attorney general, Gonzales championed policies that eroded civil liberties protections. After September 11, he authored a memo that dismissed the Geneva Conventions prohibiting torture as "quaint" and "obsolete," urging "flexibility" to interpret international law as the Bush administration saw fit.
https://www.aclusocal.org/en/news/alberto-gonzales-legacy

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
3. Yes also remember the "weapons of mass destruction" lies to promote the invasion of Iraq.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 06:49 AM
Tuesday

And lying that Iraq was tied to 9/11?

Most of the American people bought the lies or didn't care.
They loved the idea of bombing brown people to hell and back even if they were totally innocent.

So yes, the degrading of US morality and logic has been a work in progress.

rubbersole

(8,830 posts)
8. But, but yellow cake...
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:39 AM
Tuesday

...and oil. Lots and lots of oil. Rumsfeld wanted to use 9/11 to attack Iraq. On 9/12.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
22. And funnel a huge amount of money to his company Halliburton.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:00 AM
Tuesday

He was a con artist, who killed many people and ruined a country to get rich.
Along the lines of Putin.

Blue Full Moon

(1,432 posts)
10. There were reports that proved that no WMD.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:45 AM
Tuesday

Bush had stated something about yellowcake in Cincinnati OH. Which ended up being the beginning of the Plame Affair.
IAEA report was released near or just before Cincinnati comments. But what was not known was the fact that under Ronald Reagan, the Iraqis were brought to the United States of America and were taught how to operate a gaseous diffusion plant. So during the war when some centrifuge components were found it wasn't too surprising. The first centrifuge plant was ended in 1985.

27. Americans can't help buy the lies ...
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:14 AM
Tuesday

when the corrupt and compromised media smothers the truth at every turn.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
29. The US media is the propaganda arm of the PutinGOP.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:24 AM
Tuesday

The media does not work for the American people.

barbtries

(30,059 posts)
11. for me it was an interview with Karl Rove,
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:59 AM
Tuesday

I think it may have been in Vanity Fair, about that time.

He basically said out loud we create our own reality. I'm sure he's reveling today.

Simeon Salus

(1,347 posts)
4. This is the Vietnam story as well.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:02 AM
Tuesday

Kill all the local authority figures so the people have no one to guide them. Teachers, lawyers, clergy.

Blue Full Moon

(1,432 posts)
5. Uneducated are easily controlled.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:19 AM
Tuesday

They want people who will do what they are told. Do it regardless if it's illegal. They don't want people who know their rights and their worth.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
6. Yes exactly.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:23 AM
Tuesday

An educated populace is necessary for democracy to flourish.
Without education, people are easily led and fooled into believing evil is good and good is evil.

Blue Full Moon

(1,432 posts)
13. Ohio has some insidious evangelicals
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 08:11 AM
Tuesday

They believe that they should know nothing. That reading and learning is you trying to be God. They have willful ignorance that they are proud of. They take no responsibility whatsoever. That God puts people in power you should never question. Several years ago NASA had a meeting at COSI in getting children in to stem. Because we need all capable people working to solve things like climate change.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
23. Yes NASA has been working hard on stem and especially getting women into stem.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:01 AM
Tuesday

One of my cousins is part of that educational program at NASA.

28. I drove across Ohio two years ago ...
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:16 AM
Tuesday

listening to talk radio, I could NOT believe the avalanche of lies and misinformation and hate I heard. I was angry at first, then deeply sad at what we've allowed America to become.

Blue Full Moon

(1,432 posts)
33. Yes the media takeover has been complete.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:42 AM
Tuesday

All because of Nixon and wanting to go back and exonerate him. The media bias was the republicans didn't want people to know their illegal acts. Now they have the first convict president. But they still trying to pull off the law and order party.

allegorical oracle

(3,636 posts)
7. Even decent, educated people can be naive. Many are reared to be trusting and to
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:36 AM
Tuesday

think the best of people. Often, they've never encountered people like DJT -- who are so able to convincingly lie and cheat. Guess that's why the RW has considered libs to be "snowflakes".

But I prefer to believe the intelligent and educated populace will prevail. (Meanwhile, it may have to memorize books and travel somewhere to gather, survive, and restart democracy.)

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
9. Yes true. But education is the cornerstone of democracy.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 07:42 AM
Tuesday

The majority of people with a sound education in democratic principles, current events, history
are more likely to make informed choices in the voting booth.

Democracy also involves a moral core, a set of common values in rule of law,
honesty, public service and the common good.

Yes we may prevail, but history tells a great deal of damage can be done until it does.

The fight over democracy vs fascism killed over 75 million people during WWII.

allegorical oracle

(3,636 posts)
14. Oh certainly. And perhaps that's a difference between MAGA followers and those
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 08:12 AM
Tuesday

who aren't. They don't necessarily want to avoid fights while more educated people do. So they regard liberals (long labeled "peaceniks" or pacifists) to be wishy-washy weak while they are strong, macho, and willing to fight-fight-fight. DJT lit that fire in them.

I look at our situation as similar to being caught in an under-toe while you're swimming at the beach. To survive, a swimmer must go quiet -- relax as they're tossed around like laundry in a washing machine. It eventually releases so you can swim to shore. Swimmers who battle the water's force become exhausted and more likely to drown.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
24. Good point.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:03 AM
Tuesday

The PutinMAGAs want to wear out and kill their opponents.

We should be careful about our strategy.

Blue Full Moon

(1,432 posts)
17. One that the republicans have been eroding
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 08:40 AM
Tuesday

Reagan attacked the Pell Grants. Then he had school reform agenda. In fact he stated that he wasn't sure that there was any legitimate federal function to be performed in education. The democrats wanted more funding for the schools but Reagan had the belief that demand and reward performance was the way. Which everyone knows does not. Then there was Bush jr leave every child behind. So I would have to say that teaching to a standardized test has cheated our children and grandchildren out of their education.

LSparkle

(11,868 posts)
19. And to know how our system works ..
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 08:47 AM
Tuesday

So people would know when XC makes false claims about what a president can do. So they would also know what only Congress has the power to do so they could recognize he’s lying.

barbtries

(30,059 posts)
12. it's true.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 08:01 AM
Tuesday

I was over 40 before I even knew what a personality disorder is, because I was involved with a man whose behavior was like nothing I had ever experienced before.

got out alive after a year.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
25. Yes, empathy, kindness, respect, public service are now quaint old fashioned values.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:08 AM
Tuesday

They have no place in the new world we live in.

In fact these traits are seen as weak, only suckers and losers operate this way.

multigraincracker

(34,562 posts)
20. Had a friend that was a professor that taught English as a Second Language.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 08:54 AM
Tuesday

He traveled all over the world and found that in America people have the least respect for teachers. This is historical and not just recently. Most other cultures see teachers more like we do doctors and lawyers.
Here it's low pay and "if you can't do, teach".
I can think of so many teachers that changed my life. Even with all of my learning disabilities, they recognized my talents I did have and encouraged me.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
32. I agree.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:31 AM
Tuesday

I once had a Japanese neighbor living here in the US who was shocked at the how little teachers
here are valued. In Japan teachers are highly respected.

And yes I had teachers who were supportive and encouraged me.
And imparted life wisdom that helped me a great deal.

OldBaldy1701E

(6,847 posts)
26. Here is part of the issue as I see it.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:08 AM
Tuesday

We have allowed the idea of 'education' to get away from 'learning how to think critically and honestly' with tons of facts that are useless without the ability to apply them. This was the first salvo from the rethugs, who want us all to be stupid and gullible. They started in on demanding that subjects be taught that had nothing to do with reasoning and critical thinking. They also decided to ruin standard subjects by coming up with crazy ways to do what used to be simple (i.e.: 'new math' and such things). They then removed the subjects that encouraged such skills over complaints about 'wokeness' and other stupid accusations. What we are left with is something that does not do what we created it to do.

All per their design. None of this is by accident.

We need to put an end to it. By any means necessary. Otherwise, we might as well all start wearing bright red 'MAGA' hats to keep us from being noticed.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
30. Getting an education now is about making the billionaires richer.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:28 AM
Tuesday

Education must be about getting jobs which enrich corporations and make people good worker bees.

Critical thinking, logic, truth, public service, adding to society's fund of knowledge are seen as bad,
and old fashioned ideas.

Blue Full Moon

(1,432 posts)
38. Koch's were the ones that fought Biden
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 10:10 AM
Tuesday

Over the student loan forgiveness. But the Koch's were also the ones attacking our educational system. Charles Koch pushed to make our Universities to cost more. And now we have tech bros not wanting Americans to get degrees and they don't want to pay for our colleges because getting people from overseas is cheaper. Their plan all along was to break the American people to accept social class make them accept pay and benefits like we are in a third world country.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
41. Americans are victims of ongoing scams designed to make the rich richer.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 10:24 AM
Tuesday

And to give the politicians more power.

Yes we are more like a third world country than other modern democracies.

OldBaldy1701E

(6,847 posts)
42. Very true.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 10:25 AM
Tuesday

They want us to be serfs or worse. They don't care about anyone or anything but themselves.

John1956PA

(3,496 posts)
39. "Outcome-Based Education" us an example of this.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 10:14 AM
Tuesday

The goal of OBE is to get graduating seniors to score as highly as possible on the standardized test administered as they conclude their high school studies. Traditional disciplines such as deriving geometry proofs have been discarded.

bucolic_frolic

(47,963 posts)
34. Play dumb and get to work
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:43 AM
Tuesday

protect you and yours. count your beans. your time will come when the system collapses from stupidity.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
37. The billionaire scams and corruption of US politicians and judges will cause a collapse eventually?
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 09:58 AM
Tuesday

Blue Full Moon

(1,432 posts)
40. Sure, they are going to arrest themselves.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 10:15 AM
Tuesday

How much before Americans have had enough? Problem I see, is that we are there, but for the life of me, why they are putting their faith on the people that created their plight.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
43. I agree, Americans seem to love being scammed, lied to and manipulated.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 10:26 AM
Tuesday

They keep voting the criminals back in office.
And buying the crap the rich corrupt billionaires sell.

Hugin

(35,007 posts)
44. It's all a vulture signaling contest from here on out.
Tue Jan 14, 2025, 10:34 AM
Tuesday

Which lamprey can attach itself to the posterior sweet spot of the Tangeranus and hold on the longest. AKA A spoils system.

This is precisely why I could never buy into science fiction plots where there was an evil alternate universe where a comparable level of technological advancements existed. Scientific advances require working together and an acceptance that one is fallible. It also necessitates a willingness to change based on evidence and an open mind.

A feature of totalitarian culture is how sclerotic they are and it would be far more likely that in an alternate reality where it had taken hold the citizens would be sitting around in an unlit cave warily grunting at each other. Sizing each other up for a weakness leading to them being the next meal.

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
47. Brilliant metaphors.
Fri Jan 17, 2025, 03:28 PM
11 hrs ago

I am not sure I agree, I think that evil can dominate a world and succeed in some fashion.

But I hope your view is the correct one.

Blue_Tires

(57,396 posts)
45. We're in a post-truth, post-fact society
Fri Jan 17, 2025, 02:12 PM
12 hrs ago

and evidently this is what Americans wanted because we keep fucking voting for it..

Irish_Dem

(61,090 posts)
48. Yes truth, reality, facts are no longer in vogue.
Fri Jan 17, 2025, 03:37 PM
11 hrs ago

Every one now creates their very own reality.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Experts, education, scien...